Favorite brand of peanut butter Posted by Iceitic on March 19, 2012 12:00 pm 21 I'm interested in what everyone's favorite brand of peanut butter is and why. Also, crunchy or creamy? If I'm having a sandwich I prefer creamy but for topping, mostly crunchy. Peter Pan is my favorite brand. There are 21 Comments. Load 'Em Up. Show speed reading tips and settings Shortcuts to mastering the comment thread. Use wisely. C - Next Comment X - Mark as Read R - Reply Z - Mark Read & Next Shift + C - Previous Shift + A - Mark All Read Comment Settings Live comment alert: Hide it! Comments for this post are closed.