Smoked by Windows Phone
I want to say this here instead of watching it become buried in a sea of comments.
Its not about a level playing field. Its just a campaign to sell more phones by highlighting its features. Its not supposed to be even, and Microsoft isn't going into this to give away free laptops to everyone (it will however give you a "free" phone on contract reguardless of whether you win or lose).
Its a shame he didn't recieve a free laptop, but he didn't leave with any more than what he started with.
If you want to see a real test, do one yourself. I'm sure Windows Phone will perform quite well in some areas (it is very fast), and not so well in others (there is still no easy way to turn off the Wifi).