iPhone 5: Weight and Thickness vs. Greater Battery Life

Question for the Core: Would you rather have a phone the same weight/thickness as the iPhone 4S but with a proportionally bigger battery? Or do you prefer the decreased weight and thickness of the iPhone 5 in exchange for battery life?

Personally, I always thought the iPhone 4/4S was a great weight/thickness, and I'd rather have a longer-lasting battery for a slightly bigger phone. I'd consider a long-tasting LTE smartphone to be more revolutionary than "we made it slightly thinner and lighter."

To be fair, it sounds like the iPhone 5 already has great battery life for a smartphone (LTE or no), but imagine if Apple had gotten 50-100% more than that? Of course, this is all just hypothetical, and it's quite possible that the increased battery life would be too trivial to notice.