Will the dimensions of your WP8 phone be your determining factor?

When the Nokia Lumia 920 was ready to be announced I was hoping for a phone thinner than 10mm, but after the specs came rolling out, I was a bit shocked by it's thickness (10.7mm).

Now HTC presented their flagship, the 8X, and it also seems rather thick if you compare it to their One X (10.1mm versus 8.9mm).

The Samsung ATIV S on the other hand measures only at 8.7mm, but with a screen that might be too large for most at 4.8". That had me thinking: will the thickness (or other dimensions) influence my/your choice?

These are the figures:

Nokia Lumia 920

130.3
70.8 widest
10.7 thickest
185 g heaviest
4.5"

HTC 8X
132.3
66.2
10.1
130 g
4.3" smallest screen

Samsung ATIV S
137.2 tallest
70.5
8.7
135 g
4.8" largest screen

Personally I still think I'll be getting the Lumia 920 even though its dimensions don't sound good, but I have to feel it in my hands to determine if it's too thick.