Great gaming mouse under $50-60?

I currently have a Logitech M510 and I'm getting to the point of wanting to throw it out a window. Every time I try to play, it tends to lag or just not be responsive. I'm wondering if it has to do with my mousepad (all black) or the laser just sucks. I just replaced the batteries, too.

I havent been keeping track of new mouse tech lately, but I just want something that has optics that are really responsive and have no problems being used on any surface. Any good suggestions out there? I'd prefer simple black or dark grey mice. Those gaudy ones with all the lights and buttons are kinda gross. Any good mouse with 3-5 buttons is good enough :) thanks!