Is it Time to Go All Digital Yet?

With next gen consoles I'm really struggling with whether to go all digital or stay physical. The heart of the dilemma is that I'm a compulsive collector and it would drive me nuts to make the switch later.

I was super excited for the original XB1 plan where physical discs became digital but still gave you the box to display. With that out the window what should I do? Pro's and Con's?