OS consistency vs more apps... a worthy trade?

See this article by Peter Bright - Android apps on Windows Phone would be an ugly capitulation

Backing up some of the rumours we heard last week about Microsoft working on Android apps for Windows (phone and OS). He makes very good points, especially regarding the whole giving up on the platform, but I'd really like to avoid steering into the usual talking points. I want to put this question to you guys instead:

Would you give up the consistency Windows Phone currently has for Android apps? Which ones in particular?

I'll just let the discussion flow naturally.