Design
I feel like it's undisputed that the current iPhone model is probably the best looking phone on the market. When someone spends as much as we all do on a phone I think we all want it to at least feel expensive. The iPhone 4S does that. Although the all glass does scare me. I pray I never, ever, ever drop it.
Display
The retina display is nice, definitely looks nice. I suppose that is one of those things that when it is done right then you don't really notice it.
Cameras
Again, I think it's undisputed that the iPhone is the best in camera quality. I sell cameras, and I frequently think to myself how my phone takes a equally decent picture then some point and shoots. The 4S is the shining example of the future when phones replace point and shoots.
Reception/Call Quality
The call quality is good enough, I would like it to be a little louder overall. I have AT&T which is and of itself isn't really the best, but the iPhone definitely keeps up it's end of the bargain on calls.
Performance
The 4S works fine, I've owned iOS products before and it works just as good. I've had to restart it for no apparent reasons every once in a while, but overall not a huge deal. Other than that it all works nice and smooth.
Software
At this point I've become tired of iOS. It's the oldest mobile OS and it is showing it's age. It lacks a lot of features Android has and the cool UI of WP7. I'm hoping a nice and big improvement for iOS6. With that said, the OS works, it does most everything I want to do but with the competitors showing us what we can do it makes iOS frustrating.
Battery Life
Apple products are famous for good battery life, I'm not totally sure if the whole battery problem is effecting me, I assume it is. I usually have to charge my phone every night, although I don't use it too much. I would have to say that I guess I expect a little better battery life from it but that may be because I'm spoiled.
Ecosystem
The ecosystem with the 4S and iOS5 is nice, I can finally stay away from iTunes as much as possible which is nice. I enjoy iCloud for this reason. Other than that I haven't tried it with other Apple products. (I own a Windows 7 computer and no tablet)
The Breakdown
-
Design
9
-
Display
9
-
Camera(s)
10
-
Reception / call quality
8
-
Performance
9
-
Software
6
-
Battery life
7
-
Ecosystem
8
Show the rest of this review and the breakdown