Android Army
Are you in the Android clan?
1 posts
IP attorney, gadget-o-phile, [H], gamer, Evolutionary Sociobiologist
Are you in the Android clan?
1 postsAll things Apple
4 postsHome theater and beyond
0 postsThe Verge Book Club!
1 postsAchievement unlocked?
4 postsLet's talk about The Verge
6 postsLet your Microsoft flag fly
0 postsLaptops, desktops, peripherals
0 postsLaw, industry, and regulatory
5 postsOut there weirdness for creeps
0 postsCalling all photo junkies
0 postsComment
2 days ago on Just to be clear, the Hangouts video chat situation on AT&T is really messed up
Comment
Maybe, but it’s a case by case decision.
2 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
Comment
The law doesn’t agree.
The law is about who owns the material, not whether the “performance” is “worthy.”
2 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
Comment
That’s not transformative under the law. transformative means you are using the product in question as a means to create a new product, a new expression etc. So, say, Red vs. Blue uses Halo to tell a story outside of the standard Halo storyline, using comedy and ideas and concepts not found in the game itself. It’s a new expression.
But when you are just playing a game, as it was meant to be played as a game, then that’s not transformative.
LPs vs Machinimas are really good examples of this line.
2 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
Rec
Recommended Greg the Mad's comment in Chinese abductee used Google Maps to find his family after 23 years
2 days ago
Comment
And emphasizes a ridiculously prevalent practice of “forced adoptions”
2 days ago on Chinese abductee used Google Maps to find his family after 23 years
Rec
Recommended Greg the Mad's comment in Chinese abductee used Google Maps to find his family after 23 years
2 days ago
Rec
Recommended Astromanaught's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Rec
Recommended seanpat05's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Comment
But playing a game precisely as it was meant to be played isn’t transformative, and it’s barely derivative.
3 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo? 1 reply 1 recommend
Rec
Recommended srslyyou's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Comment
As a PC gamer, I have to say he’s right.
Exhibit A: The derision around the word “port”
3 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo? 1 reply 1 recommend
Rec
Recommended srslyyou's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Rec
Recommended rekh127's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Rec
Recommended jph1989's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Rec
Recommended Principia's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Comment
Reviews have long been recognized as a fair use.
3 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo? 1 reply 3 recommends
Comment
Whatt hey CAN do and what they SHOULD do are two different things. Legally, they could ask for it taken down. Instead they choose to, essentially, license it.
Should they? That’s open for debate.
3 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo? 1 recommend
Comment
Sorry, man, you don’t understand IP.
This isn’t a fair use (since it uses Nintendo’s products it HAS to fall under fair use to be ok) since it doesn’t criticize or comment on the original or anything else.
3 days ago on Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo? 2 replies 2 recommends
Rec
Recommended chrismgallen's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Rec
Recommended Iconoclysm's comment in Who owns a 'Luigi's Mansion' walkthrough video, the player or Nintendo?
3 days ago
Rec
Recommended hotleadsingerguy's comment in Leaked Scroogled video sees Microsoft parody Google's Chrome ad
3 days ago
Rec
Recommended mdtauk's comment in Leaked Scroogled video sees Microsoft parody Google's Chrome ad
3 days ago
Comment
Those are two different things. People can operate in whatever currency they want, but the US government does not have to accept them or exchange dollars from the. That is what they meant.
However, when you hold yourself out to be a currency exchange system, you’d better do your due diligence and fill out a freaking form correctly.
3 days ago on Biggest Bitcoin exchange accused of violating US financial regulations, CEO faces fine or jail 6 recommends
Rec
Recommended bokonon's comment in Google takes on Spotify with Google Play Music All Access subscription service, priced at $9.99 per month
4 days ago
Comment
Same here. Mine’s going on 7 years old, and is still fantastic. 720p as well.
4 days ago on Good Deal: Panasonic 42-inch plasma smart TV for $399.99 1 recommend
Comment
All of those other things you mentioned are easily done, and done freaking FREAKING well, in OneNote.
Greatest. App. Ever.
4 days ago on Windows RT hits a new low: just $300 for Dell's XPS 10 convertible
Comment
And the excellent options for productivity software… Oh wait again..
4 days ago on Windows RT hits a new low: just $300 for Dell's XPS 10 convertible 1 reply 5 recommends
Comment
That makes no sense. It costs A LOT more to bring these suits than they recover. I mean, they made $85k in this suit. The attorney’s fees for the Dsitrict Court, Court of appeals and SCOTUS cases (shoot, the briefs alone) cost more than that!
6 days ago on Supreme Court rules in favor of Monsanto, says farmer violated seed patents 1 reply
Comment
Incorrect. His first crop was purchased as part of a license with Monsanto. Now, where he bought them is immaterial. Just like when you buy a phone from Best Buy, you are still signing a contract with Verizon.
Then, after his first yield, he bought MORE seeds, but these were wecond generation seeds: leftovers from OTHER farmer’s crops of that same year. He wanted to plant a second crop and try to squeeze some more out of the growing season. These second generation seeds are the crux of the question: Does the license signed earlier covering monsanto’s seeds cover these second generation seeds? The SCOTUS held Yes.
6 days ago on Supreme Court rules in favor of Monsanto, says farmer violated seed patents
