Freelance animator and movie producer in Osaka, Japan.
Comment
It’s not legendary, nor is it original. Henry David Thoreau did this back in 1845. As for the need to formulate a sharp and enlightened view of life without the internet and the ever-present cell phone, just ask anybody over the age of 25 who can still remember the ancient past of the late 80s and early 90s.
Paul’s views on life are shaped by the people he hangs out with, who are apparently unapologetic about using their cell phones without consideration for those around them. I live in Japan, which still has the highest penetration of cell phones in the world (and with it, the internet), and my friends will ask before using their phones in the company of others, and apologize if it’s necessary.
Social disconnect is enabled by cell phones, but take them away and those with the tendency to block themselves off from others are bound to find an alternative outlet (comic books, novels, video games, whittling, whatever).
This experiment is self-indulgent, unoriginal, and at best good for a few more page clicks than usual. Skimming over the article turned up nothing that couldn’t already be found by reading the kinds of books they assign you in high school English, or as mentioned, talking to a few people that comprise the vast majority of humanity over the age of 25 and who doesn’t suffer the first-world problems of a tech writer in New York City.
12 days ago on Offline: Ghost limbs 1 reply
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: Ghost limbs
12 days ago
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: Ghost limbs
12 days ago
Comment
What it seems like it would be is a real challenge. The internet is becoming the next iteration in the evolution of communication; where Paul is wrong is in supporting the premise that it’s just a fun luxury. He makes his living from the internet because it is the go-to means of finding news and information. He might as well quit computers altogether, as well as cars, telephones (all of which run over IP, incidentally), and television. Most of which are networked nowadays; there is no purity in this challenge anymore. The only realistic goal of this challenge is in its attempt to garner page views.
23 days ago on Offline: day one of life without internet 2 recommends
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: day one of life without internet
23 days ago
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: day one of life without internet
23 days ago
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: day one of life without internet
23 days ago
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: day one of life without internet
23 days ago
Comment
Having an opinion you don’t agree with doesn’t make someone a troll, it just makes them someone that doesn’t agree with you. I agree that this is a pretty unimaginative stunt that is being poked fun at by people smarter than we (http://curiousrat.com/home/2012/5/2/im-giving-up-reading-for-a-year.html). The fact that we’re even commenting on an article on the internet written by somebody supposedly off the internet shows the inherent irony, if not outright hypocrisy, of Mr. Miller’s “challenge”. The first thing he did was play a local-network multiplayer game. Then he posted this piece on the internet, through a proxy, most likely, but you know what? It’s still cheating. “Off the internet” should be a two-way street, but he obviously realizes that he’ll become irrelevant if he truly embraces the spirit of this stunt. It’s lukewarm and half-hearted at best.
23 days ago on Offline: day one of life without internet 1 reply
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: day one of life without internet
23 days ago
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: day one of life without internet
23 days ago
Rec
Recommended a comment in Offline: day one of life without internet
23 days ago
