clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

ITC issues final ruling, says Motorola doesn't infringe three Apple patents

New, 4 comments

The ITC handed down its final determination on Apple's patent suit against Motorola, upholding an initial finding that Motorola didn't infringe on the three patents in question. The ruling terminates the ITC's investigation into the matter.

via <a href="http://cdn1.sbnation.com/entry_photo_images/2747266/_MG_5419_gallery_post_large_verge_medium_landscape.jpeg">cdn1.sbnation.com</a>
via cdn1.sbnation.com

The web of patent lawsuits between Apple and Motorola may have just thinned out a strand. Back in January, Motorola Mobility received an initial ruling from the ITC regarding Apple's 2010 patent infringement claim, finding that it didn't infringe on the three patents in question. Now, the ITC is handing down its final determination, backing up the original finding and terminating the ITC's investigation into the matter. While this marks the end of the road for the Commission's current investigation, Apple is likely to appeal the decision to the Federal Circuit — just as it did against HTC two months ago — so this might not be the last we hear about the patents.

The three patents under consideration are: the '828 patent, which covers "ellipse fitting for multitouch surfaces," the '430 patent, which covers an "object-oriented locator system," and the '607 patent, which covers a "multipoint touchscreen." In the ITC's ruling, the judge found that Motorola's products didn't infringe on the '807 patent. The '430 and '607 patents on the other hand were found to be infringed, but a legal exception means that Motorola is off the hook. Hopefully the rumored settlement talks start to pick up some steam and everyone can put their litigation budgets toward something more productive.