Skip to main content

The triumph and tragedy of opera in HD

The triumph and tragedy of opera in HD

Share this story

opera (sean pavone)
opera (sean pavone)

Can the grand, ceremonial experience of the opera translate to the garden-variety movie theater? At The New Yorker, author Roxana Robinson evaluates the cinema experience from the perspective of a seasoned opera-goer, finding that while the HD video broadcasts fall short of the kind of "emotional potency" and "social pyrotechnics" that exemplify New York’s Metropolitan Opera House, the close-up shots they afford give a refreshing kind of intimacy. Some of Robinson's harshest criticism is directed at the "banal, intrusive chatter" of advertisements playing before the performance starts: "instead of sinking into the delicious dream-state of opera, you distance yourself."