"Clara, be my pal. Tell me, am I a good man?"

It's the line BBC has been using to tease the new Doctor Who, which premiered over the weekend with new lead Peter Capaldi. It's a sentiment echoed somewhat in the first episode — and presumably will be a larger theme over the course of the season. Peter Capaldi, taking over for Matt Smith, gives a strong debut performance in an otherwise by-the-books episode. But with every new actor, we get a new interpretation of the Doctor — a new personality with a new outlook on his past, present, and future.

So, is the new Doctor a good man? Let's look at four key scenes from the premiere episode, "Deep Breath" — and a more general discussion between myself and Kwame Opam. Warning: spoilers.