First Click: I'd rather buy a watch in an alley than from Indiegogo

May 22nd, 2015

11

Did you know that almost every Indiegogo campaign collects money even if the project fails to meet its goal? That’s because 95 percent are set up using so-called Flexible Funding. Fixed Funding is the all-or-nothing model you’ll find employed by Kickstarter whereby money is withheld until the project meets its targets. With flexible funding, all the risk is with the consumer.

Refunds for failure to deliver? Ha, you must be joking. You can ask nicely and Indiegogo can suspend the campaign’s account, but when push comes to shove you’ll have to fight the campaign team in a US court of law to get back your money.

That leaves Indiegogo ripe for abuse, especially for gadget shoppers. This isn't new, but cheap sensors and radios coupled with disgruntled industrial engineers have combined to accelerate the glut of crap gadgets heading straight to the mainstream crowdfunding platforms. Anyone that can produce an earnest video that rises to a crescendo at just the right moment can win funding these days.

Take LunoWear for example. Bo wanted a wooden watch but “couldn’t find one that had the style and quality” he was looking for. So he turned to Kickstarter with a project titled “73 Year Old Watchmaker Launches NEWEST Watch With Grandson” featuring a lovely soft-focus video of grandpa Calvin doing lots of craftsman-y things with tweezers, tiny gears, and something that made sparks. Bo and his partner Ryan amassed $424,687 in Kickstarter pledges and even received a coveted Staff Pick award. Everyone felt great supporting this family project until identical-looking watches (for a lot less than $60) were discovered on AliExpress that probably weren’t designed by Bo’s grandfather. Kickstarter abruptly suspended the account and LunoWear received nothing of that half-million dollars. Remember, Kickstarter doesn’t convert pledges into cash contributions until a) the project ends, and b) the project meets its funding goal. The checks and balances worked.

LunoWear is now on Indiegogo as a flexible funding campaign where 1,980 people have already pledged $143,478 in cold hard cash which Bo and Ryan will collect after the campaign ends.

In 2012, Kickstarter tried to convince the world that it wasn’t a store. The $20 million recently raised by the Pebble Time proves that wrong. But if Kickstarter is a store, then Indiegogo is that guy in the alley selling watches sewn into the lining of an open trench coat. Except Indiegogo is riskier because you can't inspect the watches up close before handing over your money.

Update May 26th, 11:39AM: Clarified that Indiegogo campaigns don't get paid until after the campaign ends.

Five stories to start your day



  1. Eurovision and Nothingness: backstage with the hopefuls of Europe's biggest TV event

    In barely three hours, he and the three other members of the Danish boy band Anti Social Media will take the stage at the Eurovision Song Contest, one of the biggest — and most ridiculous — TV events in the world, and sing their official competition song, "The Way You Are." Six months ago, he was just a redheaded 19-year-old with a nice voice. By the end of the night, millions of viewers around the world will know his face and his band’s music. For the moment, though, all he can do is wait.

  2. A first look at Uber's car for self-driving research

    True to form, Uber isn't being shy about its work developing self-driving cars. In February, the company announced its plans to create autonomous vehicles, and now, one of its research cars has been seen cruising the streets of Pittsburgh. The vehicle — spotted by the Pittsburgh Business Times — has the words "Uber Advanced Technologies Center" splashed across one side, and what looks to be a box of electronic components on the roof.

  3. Paralyzed man sips beer using robot arm he controls with his mind

    Erik Sorto hasn't been able to move his arms or legs in a decade, after a gunshot wound 13 years ago rendered him quadriplegic. But after scientists implanted chips into his brain three years ago, he's been able to move a robotic arm — to shake hands; play rock, paper, scissors; and yes, drink beer, according to a study in the journal Science.

  4. Eric Shit' is the latest tech CEO to get a portrait made out of poop

    Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg was the first to be featured, but Katsu has now turned his attention to Google chairman Eric Schmidt, unveiling the wonderfully-titled portrait "Eric Shit." And in case we've not been clear on this point so far: yes, these are portraits done using Katsu's own poop.

  5. In this alternate universe, the Transformers have destroyed movie history

    In our reality, the Transformers franchise has wreaked havoc on Hollywood for the better part of a decade, and it shows no signs of stopping. But imagine, if you will, a universe where every movie you know takes place in the same world... all until the Transformers come to ruin everyone's lives.

Mario of the day

The best of Verge Video