Skip to main content

UK admits it spied illegally for 17 years, is sorry, won't stop

UK admits it spied illegally for 17 years, is sorry, won't stop

Share this story

The Chancellor Speaks Ahead Of The Spending Review At GCHQ
Photo by Ben Birchall - WPA Pool / Getty Images

After more than a year of legal struggle, the UK’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal has issued a landmark ruling on the country's secret bulk collection program. That program, first revealed by Edward Snowden, allowed the country's surveillance agency, the GCHQ, to tap internet cables and build a detailed database of the country's communications with little to no legal oversight.

The ruling has both good news and bad news for British spies. First, the bad news: the court found that, between 1998 and the tail end of 2015, GCHQ’s bulk collection program was conducted in brazen defiance of Article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights. Parliament never approved the program as legal, despite several opportunities to do so.

The bulk collection, which includes collecting a year’s worth of location records and call data from every cell phone in Britain, was kept secret from the public and outside the reach of courts. The result was a massive violation of the nation’s privacy, made public only after unauthorized disclosures by a whistleblower who is currently forbidden from entering the country.

The good news is that last November — years after the initial Snowden disclosures and months after the Privacy International lawsuit was filed — the GCHQ’s bulk collection program was changed to include more disclosure on the underlying policies, rendering it legal without affecting the underlying operations. As a result, nothing has to change, and it’s unlikely that anyone involved in the program will face repercussions of any kind.

So that’s settled then.

How to fake a fingerprint and break into a phone