First Click: Hyperloop or loopy hype?

February 12th, 2016


Elon Musk famously described Hyperloop as “a cross between a Concorde, a rail gun… and an air hockey table.” He first floated his idea for the high-speed ground transportation system in July 2012, and then again in May 2013 at the D11 conference. In August of 2013, Musk followed up his musings with a 58-page plan that laid out the fundamentals for Hyperloop Alpha, a tube designed to shoot aluminum pods carrying passengers and vehicles from LA to San Francisco at speeds of up to 800mph. That’s fast enough to cover the entire 380 mile trip from Los Angeles to San Francisco in 35 minutes.

“If it was my top priority, I could probably get [a working prototype] done in one to two years,” said Musk at the time. “But it’s going to be pretty far from my top priority.” For anyone else, Musk estimated the work would take three to four years. The LA to SF trek would take another four to five after the first functional full-scale prototype was built. That gives Musk’s original LA to SF track an estimated construction date of late 2020 or 2022.

Here we are, almost three years later, and the most visible milestone achieved to date are some disconnected tube sections scattered in the Nevada desert, and the selection of a Hyperloop pod design that will race on Musk’s yet-to-be-built test track. That’s not to say there isn’t progress though. Here’s the current status of the three most notable efforts to make Hyperloop a transportation reality:

  • Hyperloop Transport Technologies (HTT) plans to begin construction on its 5-mile, passenger-ready Hyperloop in mid-2016. The crowdsourced initiative’s COO Bibop Gresta claimed at Davos last month that HTT will have a working Hyperloop capable of transporting passengers across central California’s Quay Valley in 36 months. (Last October, Gresta claimed the company was 32 months away from that milestone). HTT’s claims are the most ambitious of the bunch, but they’re also the most dubious.
  • Hyperloop Technologies Inc. (HTI) plans to have its 1.9-mile scaled-down test track up and running on the outskirts of Las Vegas before the end of 2016. The company says you’ll be able to buy a Hyperloop ticket as early as 2020 if it continues making progress at current rates. HTI has already placed some pipes in the desert, and owns some of the fledgling industry’s most impressive-looking testing equipment.
  • Musk is taking a more reasoned and measured approach to achieve his vision. His almost 1-mile, scaled-down test track nearby the SpaceX HQ in Hawthorne California is expected to break ground in the Spring before completion in the summer. The Tesla and SpaceX CEO has not committed to commercializing the technology, but he‘s been a consistent  champion of the cause.

As you can see, we’re still a long way off from having a functioning Hyperloop between LA and San Francisco. Hell, we’re a long way off from having a Hyperloop between any two major metropolitan areas. And it’s certainly unlikely to happen in Musk’s original 2020 to 2022 timeframe.

I don’t mean to bemoan the lack progress. I celebrate the work that’s brought us this far, and applaud the interest that Hyperloop is generating in science and engineering amongst students, as well as the public at large. I’m just saying that predicting things is hard. And constructing a Hyperloop at the scale required for mass transportation is fraught with complications. Some are technical, but others will be regulatory in nature. No amount of engineering knowhow, for example, can "solve" the complex web of entrenched interests backing America’s incumbent modes of transportation (planes, trains, automobiles, and boats). Hurdles that Hyperloop developers will have to face once they’ve proven the technology actually works.

Still, predicting things is fun. So, let’s do some of our own with the advantage of hindsight.

When will a Hyperloop connect two major cities like LA and San Francisco?
Thank you for your vote
0 total votes

Five stories to start your day

  1. Google is reportedly building a completely standalone virtual reality headset

    On Sunday, it was reported that Google is working on a new VR headset that's far more advanced than Cardboard and closer to Samsung's Gear VR. But Google's upcoming virtual reality plans are in...

  2. The Life of Pablo: all the news on Kanye West's latest album

    After a number of last-minute changes, Kanye West's new album, The Life of Pablo — previously known as Swish and Waves — has debuted. Kanye played Pablo through a massive live stream on Tidal, and...

  3. A history of the Windows Start menu

    Microsoft’s Start menu is a big deal. It’s the first thing many people think of when they think of Windows, or even Microsoft. The simple Start menu has existed for more than 20 years now. It...

  4. Scientists have finally proven Einstein’s century-old theory about gravitational waves

    Scientists say they have proven the existence of gravitational waves — the ripples in space-time that stem from objects moving throughout the Universe. If true, it's the first time these waves have...

  5. Neanderthal DNA can influence everything from your skin to your cigarette habit

    Neanderthals may have died out tens of thousands of years ago, but their DNA still influences modern humans, according to a study published in Science today. Researchers from Vanderbilt University...

Hyperloop Prototype of the day

Reticulating poll splines...