First Click: does VR need a nausea rating system?


Our lives are marked by the ages we become allowed to do things. You need to be 18 to vote, 21 to drink alcohol (in the US, at least), and "this tall" to ride a rollercoaster. Certain birthdays mean you can watch new types of movies, categorized by how far they shade into the traditionally "adult" territories of sex, drugs, violence, and swearing. Maybe your movie has some mild peril, earning you a PG. Add a single F-word and you could earn a PG-13, but including actual f-ing is synonymous with the now-retired "X" rating.

But while that approach works for films, TV, and video games, with a whole slew of VR games, videos, and nebulous "experiences" on the horizon, do we need a new rating system — one for sensations?

Is such a thing even possible? Movie classification is tied to age, and the assumption that while a six-year-old probably shouldn't be watching the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, a 36-year-old has the emotional and mental maturity to discern fact from fiction and red corn syrup from real blood. But the motion sickness that can come from too much time spent in virtual reality worlds isn't locked by age. In the same way a 10-year-old can laugh their way through a rollercoaster ride that would have me screaming, crying, and praying to any deity that would listen, different people (and different stomachs) have very different reactions to VR headsets.

And those differences can't be cordoned off by age restrictions alone. Young children are still developing their nervous systems, but going fast is not a uniquely adult experience. Nor is completing a 360-degree spin, or falling down a hole, or understanding that despite the visual input from your eyes, your body is not actually moving. If we want to classify VR experiences by sensation we need some other kind of categories, just as movies and games make it clear when they feature fantasy violence, sex, or "fear."

Oculus has already made some strides in this department. The company, which shipped its first consumer Rift headset this week, categorizes games by comfort level, from "comfortable," through "moderate," to "intense." Both EVE: Valkyrie and Elite: Dangerous have been given "intense" ratings, a decision that seems to make sense — both games put you in the pilot seat of a spaceship and ask you to navigate 3D space, survive dogfights, and track enemy craft, all at speed.

Eve Valkyrie

But some early adopters have criticized the current classification system, on the grounds that some of the titles marked as intense are actually less likely to cause motion sickness than other games available for the headset. PC Invasion's Paul Younger says that while he's fine in the virtual reality of both EVE and Elite, the slow-paced exploration game Pollen turned his stomach. In my case, I had no problems bouncing at ridiculous speeds across a neon mountain range in VR music visualizer Frequency Domain, but felt claustrophobic and bug-eyed when asked to walk slowly around a virtual Japanese school.

Researchers aren't entirely sure yet why some VR games trigger such physical reactions in their players, but the inherent sensory conflict involved in entering a virtual world — when your eyes and ears are incorrectly informing your brain that you're moving — is key. So, too, is refresh rate, the measure of how many frames per second a headset is capable of displaying. If this drops below 60 per second, it can start to affect the human brain, making us feel dizzy and disoriented. Studies have also pointed to a person's posture, ethnicity, and field dependence or independence — how much of the background they absorb while looking at an object — as changing susceptibility to sickness, but much of this research was conducted before this current wave of headsets arrived on the scene.

Newer hardware like the Oculus Rift, HTC's Vive, Sony's PlayStation VR, and Samsung's Gear VR, have been developed to cut down on VR sickness, but as some attendees at the recent GDC found out, a day in a virtual world can still be physically taxing. That may be a problem we have to contend with, with certain games restricting the length of time they can be played in one sitting, but others say humans will adapt.

Longtime users, those who picked up the development versions of Oculus' Rift headset when it arrived on Kickstarter, often say it's simply a matter of "getting your VR legs," and training your brain to set out on long VR voyages. In the case of the HTC Vive, Valve boss Gabe Newell says the problem of VR sickness is non-existent, as the hardware's inbuilt tracking system can replicate real-world movements in virtual space, cutting down on the disconnect between brain and body.

As the Rift's competitors hit the market later this year, and VR reaches the mainstream, we'll find out whether Newell is right, or whether our VR games need to come with their own sensation classifications. If it's the latter, we can always just pinch them from movies: PG stands for "puke gently," R-rated indicates imminent retching, and NC-17 indicates you've got about 17 seconds before you're rendered Not Conscious.

Five stories to start your day

  1. iFixit's Oculus Rift teardown goes behind the magician's curtain

    The first consumer version of the Oculus Rift was released this week, and techies of a certain mindset have been clamoring to answer one question: how easy is this thing to take apart? Thankfully,...

  2. Google's new VR View tool allows easy embedding of 360-degree content

    Google wants to make 360-degree content more accessible for more people, and to do so is introducing a new tool: VR View. This allows developers to embed 360-degree photos and videos in their...

  3. The FBI will help unlock an iPhone and iPod in an Arkansas murder case

    The FBI will assist in unlocking an iPhone and an iPod connected to a murder case in Arkansas, the Associated Press reports, just a few days after the Bureau announced it had accessed the iPhone...

  4. You can play a new, very weird Final Fantasy XV demo right now

    You don't have to wait to get a taste of Final Fantasy XV. At its "Uncovered: Final Fantasy XV" event in Los Angeles tonight, Square Enix not only announced a new demo for the upcoming RPG, but...

  5. Elon Musk says this week's Tesla Model 3 unveiling is just 'Part 1' of 2

    Tesla CEO Elon Musk has a reputation for dribbling little hints about the company's plans on Twitter — and on the eve of the unveiling of the mass-market Model 3 near Los Angeles, he's at it again. ...

Cucumber of the day