Skip to main content

Exclusive: Facebook says it can’t serve a billion people if it’s biased about the news

Exclusive: Facebook says it can’t serve a billion people if it’s biased about the news

/

Why editorial efforts at the company aren't likely to expand

Share this story

This week’s controversy over how Facebook programs its Trending Topics section has highlighted the company’s growing power over the distribution of news — and the fear that it might one day use that power toward partisan ends. Facebook denied a Gizmodo report in which an anonymous former contractor said he was told not to feature conservative-leaning topics inside the widget. But the revelation that Trending Topics were chosen with editorial input raised new questions about Facebook’s relationship with journalism. Is it a neutral platform, as it has long asserted, or it is gradually developing a set of editorial principles?

Thursday marks the first anniversary of Instant Articles, Facebook’s quick-loading news format. Before the controversy over Trending Topics unfolded, I had pitched Facebook on a discussion about both Instant Articles and the company’s thinking around editorial values. In response, the company invited me to its headquarters in Menlo Park to meet with Will Cathcart, director of product management for the News Feed. It's arguably one of the most important jobs at the company, overseeing development of the company's most used — and most profitable — product. And while the company has not made any data available, it seems clear that the News Feed drives exponentially more traffic to news stories than the lower-profile Trending Topics, which is all but invisible on mobile devices.

"We're not interested in adding our point of view"

One of the more surprising things Cathcart told me is that the News Feed and Trending Topics are run by separate teams. News Feed drives the majority of consumption on Facebook, and while humans create the algorithms that feed it, they don’t offer oversight on individual topics. Trending Topics, on the other hand, is run by the company’s search team, and is meant to take the pulse of all current events. But on both fronts, Cathcart said, Facebook strives for neutrality. "We want this to show you what you’re most interested in," said Cathcart, who has worked at Facebook since 2010. "We’re not interested in adding our point of view — we actually don’t think that works for a billion people."

Facebook critics say the company is naïve for asserting that it can deliver the news without bias, since its algorithms are written by people. Cathcart told me that at a high level, the product does have a point of view: it privileges posts that readers are likely to find "meaningful" over ones that are merely recent, as Twitter (mostly) does. It highlights posts that it believes to be "informative" in addition to those that are merely "entertaining," because the data suggests that users prefer it that way.

But Facebook’s reach extends to so many people and countries and languages, that building editorial products that are curated by humans would not be feasible, Cathcart says. Facebook wants the News Feed to feel like it has been tailored to your unique set of interests. "We think about what we’re trying to do in a really personalized way," he says. "And so I think if you’re trying to build a product for over 1 billion people to be informed about the news that they care about, you can’t really be building a product that has judgments about particular issues, or particular publishers. Because that doesn’t match what 1 billion people around the world want." Trending Topics are less personalized by design — they're meant to reflect activity on the platform — but Facebook sees that as a math problem, rather than one to be solved with editorial judgment.

"You can't be building a product that has judgments about particular issues."

I asked Cathcart whether in five years, Facebook was still likely to have editorial teams making the sorts of judgments that are currently made in Trending Topics. "We care about creating the product that people want," he says. "Whether or not we can do that entirely with automated systems, or it’s helpful to have people help, is actually just a detail." Cathcart played down the editorial influence of the current team, suggesting its primary role was bug-fixing — ensuring that related topics appear together as a single item, for example, or preventing the keyword "lunch" from trending every day around noon.

But what about cases where people are obviously wrong? If 100 million people are posting, falsely, that Barack Obama was born in Kenya, does Facebook have a role to play in stopping that? "I think you already see that happen on the platform today," Cathcart says. "It doesn’t have anything to do with us — people post a lot of this stuff and talk about it, and other people post different points of view. And the nitty-gritty of the details of how we should be involved I actually think is less important than building a platform where if people want to talk about that, it’s really easy to talk about that and find different points of view."

In the wake of Gizmodo’s story, the US Senate called on Facebook to provide more transparency into how it selects stories to be featured. I asked Cathcart about how Facebook views calls for transparency. "The general thing we’ve done over the past couple of years, in part in response to these questions and criticisms, is to try to be more transparent about how the News Feed works in general," he says. "We talk about the algorithms we use and why we use the algorithms we use, and why we change it we talk about when we change it. [We do] a bunch of whiteboard sessions where we go through, here are the top things that the algorithm looks at, and doing a blog post every time we make a substantive change to the News Feed. I think we’re trying to be a lot more transparent about it, without being able to point to for every specific person’s News Feed, what were all the decisions that went into it."

To read the rest of my discussion with Cathcart, click here.

Today’s Storystream

Feed refreshed Two hours ago Dimorphos didn’t even see it coming

R
Twitter
Richard LawlerTwo hours ago
A direct strike at 14,000 mph.

The Double Asteroid Redirection Test (DART) scored a hit on the asteroid Dimorphos, but as Mary Beth Griggs explains, the real science work is just beginning.

Now planetary scientists will wait to see how the impact changed the asteroid’s orbit, and to download pictures from DART’s LICIACube satellite which had a front-row seat to the crash.


M
The Verge
We’re about an hour away from a space crash.

At 7:14PM ET, a NASA spacecraft is going to smash into an asteroid! Coverage of the collision — called the Double Asteroid Redirection Test — is now live.


E
Twitter
Emma RothSep 26
There’s a surprise in the sky tonight.

Jupiter will be about 367 million miles away from Earth this evening. While that may seem like a long way, it’s the closest it’s been to our home planet since 1963.

During this time, Jupiter will be visible to the naked eye (but binoculars can help). You can check where and when you can get a glimpse of the gas giant from this website.


Asian America learns how to hit back

The desperate, confused, righteous campaign to stop Asian hate

Esther WangSep 26
E
Twitter
Emma RothSep 26
Missing classic Mario?

One fan, who goes by the name Metroid Mike 64 on Twitter, just built a full-on 2D Mario game inside Super Mario Maker 2 complete with 40 levels and eight worlds.

Looking at the gameplay shared on Twitter is enough to make me want to break out my SNES, or at least buy Super Mario Maker 2 so I can play this epic retro revamp.


R
External Link
Russell BrandomSep 26
The US might still force TikTok into a data security deal with Oracle.

The New York Times says the White House is still working on TikTok’s Trump-era data security deal, which has been in a weird limbo for nearly two years now. The terms are basically the same: Oracle plays babysitter but the app doesn’t get banned. Maybe it will happen now, though?


R
Youtube
Richard LawlerSep 26
Don’t miss this dive into Guillermo del Toro’s stop-motion Pinocchio flick.

Andrew Webster and Charles Pulliam-Moore covered Netflix’s Tudum reveals (yes, it’s going to keep using that brand name) over the weekend as the streamer showed off things that haven’t been canceled yet.

Beyond The Way of the Househusband season two news and timing information about two The Witcher projects, you should make time for this incredible behind-the-scenes video showing the process of making Pinocchio.


R
External Link
Russell BrandomSep 26
Edward Snowden has been granted Russian citizenship.

The NSA whistleblower has been living in Russia for the 9 years — first as a refugee, then on a series of temporary residency permits. He applied for Russian citizenship in November 2020, but has said he won’t renounce his status as a U.S. citizen.


E
External Link
Emma RothSep 26
Netflix’s gaming bet gets even bigger.

Even though fewer than one percent of Netflix subscribers have tried its mobile games, Netflix just opened up another studio in Finland after acquiring the Helsinki-based Next Games earlier this year.

The former vice president of Zynga Games, Marko Lastikka, will serve as the studio director. His track record includes working on SimCity BuildIt for EA and FarmVille 3.


A
External Link
Vietnam’s EV aspirant is giving big Potemkin village vibes

Idle equipment, absent workers, deserted villages, an empty swimming pool. VinFast is Vietnam’s answer to Tesla, with the goal of making 1 million EVs in the next 5-6 years to sell to customers US, Canada and Europe. With these lofty goals, the company invited a bunch of social media influencers, as well as some auto journalists, on a “a four-day, multicity extravaganza” that seemed more weird than convincing, according to Bloomberg.


J
James VincentSep 26
Today, 39 years ago, the world didn’t end.

And it’s thanks to one man: Stanislav Petrov, a USSR military officer who, on September 26th, 1983, took the decision not to launch a retaliatory nuclear attack against the US. Petrov correctly guessed that satellite readings showing inbound nukes were faulty, and so likely saved the world from nuclear war. As journalist Tom Chivers put it on Twitter, “Happy Stanislav Petrov Day to those who celebrate!” Read more about Petrov’s life here.


Soviet Colonel who prevented 1983 nuclear response
Photo by Scott Peterson/Getty Images
J
The Verge
James VincentSep 26
Deepfakes were made for Disney.

You might have seen the news this weekend that the voice of James Earl Jones is being cloned using AI so his performance as Darth Vader in Star Wars can live on forever.

Reading the story, it struck me how perfect deepfakes are for Disney — a company that profits from original characters, fans' nostalgia, and an uncanny ability to twist copyright law to its liking. And now, with deepfakes, Disney’s most iconic performances will live on forever, ensuring the magic never dies.


E
External Link
Hurricane Fiona ratcheted up tensions about crypto bros in Puerto Rico.

“An official emergency has been declared, which means in the tax program, your physical presence time is suspended,” a crypto investor posted on TikTok. “So I am headed out of the island.” Perhaps predictably, locals are furious.


R
The Verge
Richard LawlerSep 26
Teen hacking suspect linked to GTA 6 leak and Uber security breach charged in London.

City of London police tweeted Saturday that the teenager arrested on suspicion of hacking has been charged with “two counts of breach of bail conditions and two counts of computer misuse.”

They haven’t confirmed any connection with the GTA 6 leak or Uber hack, but the details line up with those incidents, as well as a suspect arrested this spring for the Lapsus$ breaches.