First Click: Is Google right to axe the Ara modular phone?

September 2nd, 2016


Wow, it’s the end of an ara at Google, Project Ara to be specific, Google’s ambitious modular phone project. I woke up this morning to the Reuters exclusive, citing Alphabet’s desire to kill the initiative in an effort to further streamline the company's hardware efforts.

Project Ara had its share of fans especially in its original interpretation, inspired by Dave Hakkens’ 2013 Phonebloks concept. A phone that could be upgraded over the years and help reduce electronic waste was so utterly Googley that it was hard not to like it. But Google’s engineers soon found that the early modular-everything design was too unrealistic to bring to market. So in May, it announced a compromised vision with an ecosystem built around an Ara frame that included non-removable components like the display, battery, CPU / GPU, memory, and sensors. It had its fans, but many more detractors, with some calling it a boondoggle and others saying the new Ara was too heavily compromised. Even Hakkens himself, voiced displeasure.

At the time, our Ara poll showed that 75 percent of those who responded would only buy Ara if it was priced the same or less than an equivalently specced iPhone or Samsung Galaxy flagship. In other words, few saw Ara’s modularity as added value.

So, assuming the story now corroborated by sources speaking to Reuters, Recode, and The New York Times is true, what do you think? Was Google right to axe the Ara phone?

Is Google right to axe the Ara modular phone?
Thank you for your vote
0 total votes

Five stories to start your day

  1. Samsung recalls Galaxy Note 7 worldwide due to exploding battery fears

    Samsung has announced an unprecedented recall of the Galaxy Note 7 just weeks after launching the well-received smartphone. Sales have been halted globally, and over the coming weeks Samsung will...

  2. Google reportedly cancels Project Ara modular smartphone plans

    Google has "suspended" work on Project Ara, the initiative to build a phone with interchangeable modules for various components like cameras and batteries, according to Reuters and Recode. The...

  3. How the Falcon 9 explosion may change SpaceX's launch schedule

    While it’s still too early to know all the consequences of this morning’s SpaceX explosion, one thing is almost certain: the company’s future launches are likely to be delayed. We don’t know...

  4. Sony is betting the Xperia XZ and X Compact on an unconvincing camera

    I know it’s true of every modern phone, but it’s especially true of Sony’s new pair of Xperia handsets: the camera will be the most important factor in deciding the fortunes of the Xperia XZ and...

  5. Putin on DNC hacking allegations: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Vladimir Putin insists that Russia had nothing to do with the hacking of Democratic National Committee (DNC) emails and documents in July, though he says it's a good thing that the information is...

Era of the day

Reticulating poll splines...

Loading comments...