Skip to main content

House Republicans demand answers from Alphabet following Gmail privacy scandal

House Republicans demand answers from Alphabet following Gmail privacy scandal


There’s some pretty detailed questions in the letters too

Share this story

capitol dome

Last week, reports surfaced confirming that third-party app developers were capable of reading emails belonging to millions of Gmail accounts. Today, Congress is demanding Google supply answers to a variety of privacy-related questions following the scandal.

Top Republicans on the House Energy and Commerce Committee sent letters to both Apple and Alphabet today that asked a slew of questions regarding privacy issues. The most targeted questions were aimed at Alphabet’s CEO, Larry Page, regarding last week’s report in The Wall Street Journal, but also extended to issues like audio collection and location tracking.

The most targeted questions were aimed at Alphabet’s CEO

The committee pointed out that even though Google announced last year that it would stop scanning user emails to better target advertisements, the company still allowed third-parties to peer into emails and content, raising privacy concerns. These third-parties were able to look in after users allowed them access by checking off on a significantly vague approval box. “Google still permitted third parties to access the contents of users’ emails, including message text, email signatures, and receipt data, to personalize content,” the letter said. “In the context of free services offered by third parties, these practices raise questions about how representations made by a platform are carried out in practice.”

In the letter to Tim Cook, congressional Republicans ask about their perceived hypocrisy in Apple touting how committed the company is to privacy, but also allowing apps created by Google and Facebook, which the committee called “contradictory to Apple’s values,” to be downloaded through the App Store. “These statements and actions raise questions about how Apple device users’ data is protected and when it is shared and compiled,” the letter said.

When it came to other data collection questions, the lawmakers seemed curious as to whether locally stored location information on a device could be shared to Google, Apple, or third-party developers even if users turned off their location services. The lawmakers also seemed concerned whether audio could be recorded from devices even if a trigger phrase like “Okay, Google” isn’t said.

Overall, the questions were detailed and should provide some insight into how data is serviced to third-party players by both Apple and Google. The committee requested that all questions be answered and returned by July 23rd.