Artist accuses Snapchat of ripping off her design for a filter

Screenshot from Sara M. Lyons

Sara M. Lyons, a California-based illustrator and designer, has accused Snapchat of ripping off her design for one of its filters. The design in question, a pair of hands making the “whatever” sign, was a filter available to some users last night and this morning.

Lyons points out on Twitter that although her original design is fairly simple, the finger placement in Snapchat’s filter (above) and her own illustration (below) is very similar. Lyons says Snapchat’s filter looks like a traced and flipped version of her illustration.

“I had about a dozen DMs about it on my Instagram when I woke up this morning,” Lyons told The Verge via email. “I might not have noticed it on my own because I don't use Snapchat every day, but I'm fortunate to have lots of friends and followers who recognize my work.”

Lyons says she has officially registered the design with the US Copyright Office; she also sells pins of it in her online store.

This is not the first time Snapchat has been accused of stealing the work of indie artists. In 2016, The Ringer’s Molly McHugh reported that Snapchat was apparently cribbing filter ideas from makeup artists and other graphic artists. That same year, a colorful geometric face filter appeared to heavily borrow from the work of Russian artist Alexander Khokhlov. Snapchat eventually removed the filter, calling it an “embarrassing mistake.”

In the Ringer report, McHugh notes that it would be difficult to argue a court case against Snapchat for copyright infringement because it’s tough to “quantify the value of a filter.” On Twitter, Lyons has asked Snapchat to get in touch with her personally.

“It'd be amazing if Snapchat reached out directly to make things right,” Lyons said. “However, my copyright has been infringed on this piece and others countless times since 2013, and in my experience it's pretty rare that brands do right by artists in cases like these. I like Snapchat, so hopefully they'll be one of the exceptions to the rule.”

When reached for comment, a Snapchat spokesperson provided the following statement to The Verge: “We became aware of similarities between a new Snapchat Geofilter and one of Ms. Lyons' designs early today. While there are important differences between the two designs, out of respect for Ms. Lyons we decided to disable the filter immediately while we investigated. It was removed from Snapchat this morning.”

Update 6:28PM ET: Updated to add Snapchat’s statement.

Comments

Snapchat is already dead. All will be forgiven.

Maybe inspired by, but not that closely copied. It’s not an unknown hand sign either.

It’s far too similar. The palms could have faced away; the fingers even fall the same way. The banner shape, and position – both virtually the same.

Your are absolutely right.

By the way, I made a logo for a vegetable company. Hope you like it.
It was inspired by, but not that closely copied, another logo.

Best. Reply. Ever.
Still laughing.

Looks exactly copied to me. Flip it horizontally and look at the fingers.

Scottish wrestler Wolfgang has been doing that sign since at least 2010.

Alicia Silverstone was doing it in Clueless in 1995.

She may or may not have a case, but it would not be surprising if Snapchat swiped her design.

Seems like such a basic idea that two people could distinctly have that same idea… meh.

Yes, it’s not a unique idea or hand gesture, but if you look at the way it’s drawn it is nearly a mirror image. The finger positions are so similar.

Generic hand sign. I mean, eh – ask 50 people to draw the W with hands and I am sure half of them will look similar.

If she’d waited a week or two she could have included Facebook / Instagram in her complaint too.

View All Comments
Back to top ↑