WhatsApp reportedly refused to build a backdoor for the UK government

Messaging service WhatsApp rejected a UK Government request to create a way to access encrypted messages earlier this year, reports Sky News, citing an anonymous security source. The British Government reportedly asked WhatsApp in a meeting during summer to produce technical solutions that would allow access — known as a backdoor. Sky News reports that 80 percent of investigations into terrorism and serious crime are affected by encryption.

"It is crucially important that we can access their communications — and when we can't, it can provide a black hole for investigators," the source said. Extremists are known to use encryption apps like WhatsApp and Telegram to communicate, and an inability to access those messages has been a constant source of frustration for law enforcement.

Sky News reports that UK intelligence officials believe that reaching a compromise with these tech companies is possible and are firm in the hope that encrypted messages can be accessed with a warrant. Major tech companies have been strongly opposed to building backdoors though because it would undermine their services’ security, so a compromise doesn’t look likely.

In a statement on its website, WhatsApp says that “we carefully review, validate, and respond to law enforcement requests based on applicable law and policy, and we prioritize responses to emergency requests.” Apps like WhatsApp use end-to-end encryption that scrambles messages through a code. So WhatsApp can only hand over metadata like the account name and email address and can’t see the actual messages being sent.

It’s not the first time the UK Government has tried to access messages sent on the platform. Earlier this year UK home secretary Amber Rudd said it was "completely unacceptable" that intelligence services could not read WhatsApp messages sent and received by Khalid Masood, the perpetrator of a terrorist attack at Westminster in London in March.

Past incidents like the San Bernardino attack saw an exhausting court case against Apple for access to the suspects’ phones and only ended when the FBI found a work around to access the data.

Creating a backdoor would be problematic, as some in the tech community have already pointed out. Apple’s Tim Cook has previously said that weakening encryption would hurt the public, while terrorists would just find new ways to communicate.


Why would they? Facebook can simply tell the UK govt to request the info directly from the U.S. govt as both govts share information about their citizens with each other.

Its all about cost cutting, streamlining and efficiency these days

Well Facebook has given the US a backdoor, and the UK can just ask the US for any info. But since most intelligence gathering is for economic & corporate reasons, if any info requested would hurt US corporations, the UK wouldn’t stand a chance of getting it.

Good. The current bunch of authoritarians are not to be trusted, not to mention that their collective understanding of the implications of their tech related decisions leaves a great deal to be desired. Cf The Daily Mail’s frequent headlines about how the usual tech giants are almost entirely responsible for each successive atrocity, as though it is the only use anyone puts the internet to.

Good for WhatsApp.

Compromising legitimate users privacy to give the illusion of enhanced security is no way to go.

Frigg the UK government.

View All Comments
Back to top ↑